Subscribe and get breaking news, commentary, and opinions on law firms, lawyers, law schools, lawsuits, judges, and more.
Montana is really doing its level best to make life difficult for trans people. Specifically, the Montana Department of Health and Human Services recently enacted a rule that prevents transgender people from changing their gender on their birth certificate. Besides the obvious moral issue with such a rule, there’s pending litigation over a Montana law that increased the barriers to changing the gender on a birth certificate and, more to the point, the judge in that case issued a temporary injunction in April preventing the enforcement of that law. So it sure looks like the state tried to circumvent the injunction.
And that’s exactly how District Court Judge Michael Moses saw it. He blocked the new state rule, and he was pretty salty about the effort to get around his April order. As reported by Huffington Post:
Moses said his April ruling had been “clear as a bell” and compared the state’s subsequent actions to a person twice convicted of assault who tries to change their name following a third offense to avoid prosecution.
“Isn’t that exactly what happened here?” Moses asked. “I’m a bit offended the department thinks they can do anything they want.”
The state defended the adoption of the new rule, despite the injunction:
State officials denied that the new rule preventing changes to birth certificates was adopted in bad faith. Montana Assistant Solicitor Kathleen Smithgall said the state came up with the new rule to fill a gap in regulations after the 2021 law was blocked.
But Moses was having none of that. He made it clear the injunction returned the birth certificate amending process to the 2017 rules until the litigation is decided.
But it looks like Montana is ignoring the judge.
Sure sounds like Montana officials are saying they’re just going to ignore a court’s order from today in an ongoing dispute over trans people’s birth certificates. https://t.co/iB6bjr7yMy
— Chris “Subscribe to Law Dork!” Geidner (@chrisgeidner) September 15, 2022
Law professor Carl Tobias noted this could open the state up for contempt charges:
“Appeal is what you contemplate — not that you can nullify a judge’s orders. Otherwise, people just wouldn’t obey the law,” Tobias said. “The system can’t work that way.”′
The move could leave state officials open to contempt of court charges, which in some cases can lead to jail time for offenders, Tobias said. He added that the attorneys representing the state were likely aware of the potential consequences but were “caught in the middle” between a recalcitrant agency and the judge.
Not that actual consequences are likely to change the calculated political move by the state. And if weakening the judiciary is the impact of that political victory, well, that isn’t even part of the calculus.
Just file this away with [gestures wildly around at everything] the eroding respect for the rule of law in this country.
Kathryn Rubino is a Senior Editor at Above the Law, host of The Jabot podcast, and co-host of Thinking Like A Lawyer. AtL tipsters are the best, so please connect with her. Feel free to email her with any tips, questions, or comments and follow her on Twitter (@Kathryn1).
Benchslaps, Courts, Michael Moses, Montana, Rule of Law, Transgender Rights
We will never sell or share your information without your consent. See our privacy policy.
Red Flag Walking: Judge Aileen Cannon’s special master order is gobbledygook. Maybe she’s hoping it will skate by and only earn the new Red Stripe Flag!
Meanwhile…: While Trump judges kneecap national security and force the DOJ to go through the accepted appellate process, Trumpist officials in Montana express that they’re just going to ignore the benchslapping they received. Welcome to the double standard.
If At First You Fail… Burn It All Down: Rather than admit gay people are human beings, Yeshiva just shuts down every club.
Maybe The Library Will Give Them A Speaking Slot: Dershowitz’s Martha’s Vineyard neighbors open their arms to victims of Florida’s human trafficking operation.
Back To The Office: Ropes moving forward with mandatory three-day office schedule. Nobody likes it, but at a certain point young associates need someone in the room to teach them.
Our Sites
© 2022 Breaking Media, Inc. All rights reserved. Registration or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.
Privacy Center | Do not sell my information
